#OneBookWednesday: Why Not Just Watch the Movie?

By Julie B. RSS Wed, November 25, 2015

I’m gonna read it... Oh, it’s going to be the next book I pick up... everyone I know has been talking about it, so I will definitely read it...

… is maybe what goes through your head as One Book, One Philadelphia season approaches. You want to have something to contribute at that discussion group at your neighborhood library, and to have some idea of what they are talking about at that panel discussion. So if you are squeezed for time, would it really be so bad to just watch the movie instead?

This One Book season—which features Charles Frazier’s modern classic Cold Mountain, plus two companion titles, Twelve Years a Slave by Solomon Northup and The Civil War by Geoffrey Ward with Ric Burns and Ken Burns—is unique in that ALL these selections have EXCELLENT movie versions. Many Library locations will be hosting viewing parties for the films in February and March.

So would it really be so bad to cozy up with some Academy Award nominees ahead of time? What would you miss?

I am a book devotee. Rarely do I think a movie does a book justice, and as a rule I really try to read a book before seeing its movie version. But I find myself in the rare position (for me) of having seen the movies Cold Mountain and 12 Years a Slave already, and now diving into the books in anticipation of this One Book season.

So I am in a unique position to tell you exactly what you would miss if you skip the book—and I have to say, I don’t recommend doing it!

Cold Mountain, directed by Anthony Minghella and starring Jude Law, Nicole Kidman, and Renée Zellweger, hit theaters in 2003, six years after the book came out to critical acclaim. Zellweger won an Oscar for Best Actress in a Supporting Role, and the film received six other nominations. Movie reviewer Philip French, writing in The Guardian, said, “The movie is like a rougher, tougher Southern treatment of Little Women or an other-ranks version of Gone With the Wind with wooden houses rather than Palladian mansions.”

So yes, it is an excellent film, and it helps viewers envision what life looked like during the Civil War. Yet there is somewhat of a detachment from the characters, because you aren’t inside their heads, as you are in the book. This is the type of movie that is perfect to see after reading, because you already feel close to the characters, and you can insert their back stories and ideas into the action—while seeing this world you have gotten to know now come to life.

In contrast, reading the book Twelve Years a Slave and seeing the movie 12 Years a Slave are actually two very different experiences. Reading Solomon Northup’s narrative gives you a look into the mind of someone who went through it—his pain, anger, confusion, and humanity. These are the words of a real person, who endured impossible hardship and cruelty and then lived to write it all down for us.

The movie, which was directed by Steve McQueen in 2013 and starred Chiwetel Ejiofor, took home three Oscars—including Best Picture—and was nominated for six others. It is unlike anything else that has been put to film. New York Times reviewer Manohla Dargis says, “In large part, 12 Years a Slave is an argument about American slavery that, in image after image, both reveals it as a system (signified in one scene by the sights and ominous, mechanical sounds of a boat water wheel) and demolishes its canards, myths, and cherished symbols.”

And that is the key difference—seeing this film feels like seeing the system of slavery. It gives viewers a searing visual image of this terrible institution; it is sometimes very difficult to watch. The book, on the other hand, feels much more personal.

In the book readers encounter, “My wrists and ankles, and the cords of my legs and arms began to swell, burying the rope that bound them into the swollen flesh.” And in reading those words, we work to create an image in our minds that feels impossible. Our mind has to fight to comprehend this account. In the film, you SEE this horrific image—the work has been done for you, and still it is more awful that what you could have imagined. Both words and image pack incredible punches—just different ones.

In the end, the goal of One Book is to engage as a community in a collective discussion on issues that touch us all. We believe that words on the page are still the best way to initiate that conversation. But our season is also crafted to open multiple pathways to that discussion—through history, art, food, music, nature, and more.

So be it through book, film, internet review, SparkNotes, or just deciding to walk through the door to an event—please do join us in February!

Leave this field empty

Add a Comment to #OneBookWednesday: Why Not Just Watch the Movie?

Email is kept private and will not be displayed publicly
Comment must be less than 3000 characters